A Node in the Web of the Emerging Church
Emergent Village Weblog

Emerging Leadership and Cross-Gender Friendships

Posted Aug 16, 04:56 PM | 6 comments | by Editor | Link

Dan and Sheila Brennan

By Dan Brennan, re-posted from Faith Dance:

Almost exactly two years ago, Sheila and I began attending an emerging community. We felt that support from a church was important as I wrote a book on cross-gender friendship (cgf). We had no idea when we came to Life on the Vine what that would look like. We were hoping leaders would at least be “open” to rethinking traditional evangelical social constructs of male-female relationships. More and more Christians are doing so. During a recent stop in Seattle, Brian McLaren specifically encouraged local Christian leaders to pursue close friendships with the other gender in their community, according to my friend Jennifer’s first-hand report. However, this is not a post about the most popular voices in the emerging movement, but a reflection on the local community. It is to be expected, because of the diversity within the emerging conversation, that there would be diverse reactions on cross-gender friendship in local communities.

After two years in an emerging community, I share some thoughts …

I don’t think I would be where I am today without the rich encouragement of the leadership in my local community. I am quite sure, out of all the stories David Fitch has heard from newcomers checking out a church, I hold the unique distinction of being the first person to probe David for a sense of where he stood on the issue of cross-gender friendships before I even started attending. It could be one of the rare times such a thing has ever happened, but, as my regular blog readers know, Sheila and I were looking for a community that could support my desire to write a provocative book on cgfs. Since David had just finished writing his own provocative critique on evangelicalism, I figured I had a halfway decent chance of at least getting an open ear.

I expected some serious pushback from him initially—and he didn’t disappoint me. :-) The pushback started coming when he began to understand that I wasn’t intending to write a generic book on men and women getting along in cordial friendliness. This was the first time we had ever talked, and I am sure the conversation had David processing things like he had never processed before. But Sheila and I didn’t want to begin to sink roots into a community, and get deep into the book, only to find leadership drawing conventional sex-segregated lines like what had just happened to us. So I expected David to pepper me with questions once it started to sink in, and he did! I could tell he was able to get some inkling of what I wanted to write about by the nature of his questions towards me. I couldn’t tell if he was surprised by my reactions, but I sensed that he knew I had given serious thought and attention to the subject. I thought we had a good conversation. Toward the end, it seemed like he was cautiously open. Even though it was a brief prayer, David offered to pray for me at the end of the conversation, and he prayed a prayer of blessing for me, Sheila, and my book aspirations! I can’t tell you how much this ministered to me after having had this conversation six weeks earlier.

It touched my soul and gave me renewed hope that emerging leadership at a local level could do something much deeper in drawing men and women together than just focusing on equality and justice—even though those are two big issues in the contemporary conversation between the sexes.

Emerging leaders (I am speaking of men here) cannot move the conversation forward if they see women as “dangerous” or “inferior.” Furthermore, they will not be able to advance healing if they themselves are afraid of getting close to women in ministry and friendship. Again, it’s one thing to be friends with a woman blogger who lives 300 or 1,000 miles away from you. Blogging friendships at the grassroots level among emerging Christians are great and much needed, but it’s a whole different animal if you are talking about practicing close cross-gender friendships in a local community.

Within a few weeks of our attending LOTV, once the leaders saw Sheila’s enthusiastic support of my book and my friendships, they have never looked back. They have welcomed me with open arms and have prayed with me and for me. They have encouraged me in my aspirations to get this book published. And, with their encouragement, I’ve had the opportunities to begin forming friendships with men and women in the local community.

One thing I have seen emerging leaders embrace at the grassroots level in local community is organic movement and direction of love, ministry, justice, and reconciliation among “neighbors.” All of that happens when men and women begin to form and sustain trusting friendships of missional and transformational depth.


Dan BrennanDan Brennan has been happily married to his wife, Sheila, for 27 years. He is in management in a Chicago area limousine company and is writing a book on cross-gender friendships.

Bookmark this article using Remarkable!

Welcome to the Reader's Forum

1Lisa Aug 17, 08:13 PM

Dan, I am standing up and cheering you on! I can’t wait for the book to appear. We are beginning to discuss this in our church now. I am one of two co-pastors (male and female) and this is an important issue for us as we develop a new community of faith. People regardless of any signifier have so much to contribute and gain from community. If over half (which is true in most cases) of these are women and are never allowed access to the hearts and minds of those who make decisions (and vice versa), we have to ask in what way the church can truly minister to them.

I believe with all my heart that there must be “another way” than separation and isolation. Acknowledging the challenges and issues and actually dealing with them instead of hiding from them seems to be a good first step!

Thanks so much for your work! Can’t wait to read it.

2Dan Brennan Aug 18, 12:44 AM

Hi Lisa,

Thank you, Lisa. We are at a great moment in history it seems to me, to see God moving in our churches and world beyond conventional, stereotypical male-female relating—and one expression of that is the formation of deep female-male friendships in community. Equality—not a modern meaning of equality which means sameness—is important for emerging community. But friendship opens the door beyond a mere institutional getting along with the each other—to a deeper missional movement of the new creation.

3kathy escobar Aug 19, 11:26 PM

this is great to hear & i appreciate your heart & passion to pursue this important topic more intentionally. like lisa, i co-pastor with someone who is not my husband & on a team of men & women who are truly friends. our community is filled with all kinds of cross-gender friendships. a culture of diversity & equality creates healing & restoration & spiritual transformation in all kinds of ways. we need each other, brothers & sisters on the journey. i do believe the fear of sexual stuff getting in the way has so limited this critical piece of true community & i’d love to see more and more people step into new relationships that will challenge us to learn, grow, risk, change, be transformed more and more into Christ’s likeness.

4Simon Hall Aug 20, 01:44 AM

No comments from men yet! So I shall step in…

I have two different thoughts. One is a memory of working in an office while I was planting a church. I found that I got ‘into trouble’ at work because I made friends with both men and women, which apparently was not normal practice. I soon discovered that the office ran something like a Junior High disco, with the boys on one side and the girls on the other. Crossing the floor had only one purpose. I must admit I was shocked to find myself the most liberated person in our supposedly liberated times.

My other thought is best summed up by the Northern Irish group The Divine Comedy: ‘I fall in love with someone/Practically every day/It’s just the price I pay/For being a man.’ There is a reason why most fathers distrust their daughters’ boyfriends, and that is because they know themselves.

Dan, I applaud your challenge to boundaries around human relating, but I wonder how you and Sheila surf the waves of human emotion in real life?

5Dan Brennan Aug 20, 01:52 AM

Hi Kathy,

Great to hear about your community! Perhaps two words could summarize my book re Christian spirituality and sexuality in cgfs: Much more. I have whole chapters written around “much more.” Having had two close cgfs for six plus years now and counting—there is so much more we can do in confession, authenticity, play, prayer, and intimacy—in both extramarital dyad cgfs and communal connections beyond dyadic relationships. Risk, vulnerability, trust, play, formation—those are all sweet realities in dyadic cgfs.

6Dan Brennan Aug 20, 02:44 AM

Hi Simon,

I’m not exactly clear on what you meant by your question. We do have emotionally close relationships and we both are aware of the “intensity” in those friendships.

Close friendships (and I am speaking here of not just play or activity oriented togetherness, but self-disclosure and vulnerability) shapes and forms us. Friendships shape marriage (in the sense of close friends supporting and impacting the marriage)and marriage shapes friendships.

My two close cgfs love Sheila very deeply and Sheila knows them very well, and vice versa.

Add a comment











Add Emergent Village to

RSS/XML Feed

Join our mailing list: